Normally, this is said due to the fact aesthetic permit to the author’s area

Have a tendency to when times are given, he’s offered having a day of one’s week one really does maybe not suits with that time since it inside actual records. One example happens in Harry Potter and Prisoner away from Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney relates to 16 Oct since Tuesday, even if 16 Oct 1993 was a tuesday.

There are even contradictions in books in this field. Eg, in the Harry Potter in addition to Goblet out of Flame, each other step 1 September and dos September are given while the Mondays and, into the Harry Potter together with Prisoner out of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is decided towards the 20 April, but mindful parsing of text message reveals that it might has actually took place no afterwards than March.

Also, from inside the Harry Potter in addition to Goblet of Fire they do say your Champions was in fact chosen into the Tuesday 29 October, however, 30 Oct is a saturday in the 1994.

For the a bankruptcy proceeding from Quidditch From Ages, it is said the first Quidditch Community Cup occured within the 1473. In case your title try held all several years, this issues with the declaration when you look at the Goblet of Flames that the 1994 Business Glass try the fresh new 422nd. When the Quidditch Through the Age is great, the latest 422nd Quidditch Industry Cup carry out in reality belong the season 3161, however, if Cup from Fire is great, the first Industry Cup got stored inside 306.

Historic difficulties [ ]

As the series, according to timeline produced by the fresh new Chamber of Secrets source, is set about 1990s, the fresh series commonly appears as if it is place in the new later nineties to help you mid-2000s, about concurrent towards book of one’s instructions. In the Harry Potter and the Half of-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a masculine pronoun to refer toward “predecessor” of your own Finest Minister of one’s British. With respect to the significantly more than schedule, this should take place in the summer months regarding 1996, in the event that Finest Minister is John Biggest, whose quick predecessor was a lady (is why first ending up in Fudge, the book states new election, but Biggest was not initially opted and only got more than shortly after Thatcher resigned.

It’s possible, but not impractical, you to definitely Fudge could well be writing on a faraway ancestor, since Thatcher grabbed workplace before Fudge allegedly turned into Minister getting Miracle. (Although one can consider a scenario where Fudge are delegated by Minister to have Wonders to meet up with into Prime Minister while he, Fudge, was in a smaller office.) At exactly the same time, the latest character and you can reputation for the prime Minister illustrated appears to so much more directly matches regarding Tony Blair than of John Biggest. A post about Day-after-day Mail notes you to Rowling try personal to your upcoming-Chancellor of one’s Exchequer Gordon Brown (usually regarded as a rival so you’re able to Blair’s leaders of the Work Party, whom been successful your and became Prime Minister), hence she might have been trying to tell you Blair’s worst side. When your instructions have been place in connect that have guide date of Philosopher’s Stone, up coming it feel create take place in 2002 (shortly after Blair turned Prime Minister).

Yet not, it had been later reported that 22 November is a friday, that it was at 1994

The same state comes to Nicolas Flamel, who had been etsivГ¤t Sri Lanka-naisia said as being 665 at the time of the newest basic publication, however, Nicolas Flamel was a bona-fide historic figure and wouldn’t have reached one to ages until 1996, inside the day the first book are published. The brand new rebuttal for it is the fact that the day brand new “real” Nicolas Flamel came into this world doesn’t talk to the Nicolas Flamel of Harry Potter.

Another type of state can be found out of Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure given that Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s implied on the collection one Hagrid obtained you to definitely condition inside many years from his expulsion out-of college in the 1942. In one to world out-of Harry Potter together with Goblet out of Fire, Molly Weasley reminisces on the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently overlap with Molly’s decades in school, it looks unrealistic one to she remembers an earlier gamekeeper. not, it’s possible that Hagrid didn’t getting a gamekeeper instantly just after getting expelled, but instead started while the Ogg’s secretary. This will be probable as the whenever Harry thinks that he usually getting expelled for traveling to the broomstick in the place of consent inside the first 12 months, the guy secret in the event the he’d be permitted to stay on as the Hagrid’s secretary.